Thanks for the Feedback Grim.
Also Sarugon, I also want to point out, that I thought the looting was fair while with Redeemed, McFierce would hand out loots according to Main Spec, Secondary Spec.
After a time, of playing this game and after raiding so much, our toons will have all the epic drops, so when someone who doesn't raid as often decides to raid, most of the loot will be there's anyway, because all the "hardcore" raiders would have gotten most of the loots from raiding so much anyway.
As a matter of fact, now that I think of it, there were times when I raided with Redeemed and there was someone who was on in "blues" raiding a 25man raid, and he pretty much got every single loot that dropped, not because he had crappy gear, but because everyone else had that loot or even better. Most of the time the "hardcore" raiders, raided for badges and not necessarily the drops.
So again, it just depends on your playing style, there will be people who LOVE to raid and there will be people who don't care much for it, heck there will be people who probably don't care for casual or raiding, but rather focus strictly on PvP. Don't fret on where this guild will go, just know that a part of it will focus on Raiding, it is a must, that shouldn't even come into question. And yet, part of it will be casual/fun and some of it may be PvP.
just wait until Grim comes up with the policies for Raiding and Game playing, from there we can make amendments.