I think he is a person of integrety. I've never seen him do anything really stupid or unfair on the battlefeild. He tends to leave lowbies alone, he's not all about red=dead and he is a good challange in PvP. I've seen him drop into bear form with 9k life. That dropped my jaw. Genarally speaking, in a game like WoW, I think there are three types of people: Those who are recognized because of their honor, those who are recognize because of their severe lack of honor, and those who think they are being recognized for one or the other.
I would consider Peanut as an honourable player.